Skip to content
  • About
  • Institute
    • Blog
    • Background Briefings
    • Issue Resources
    • Historical Documents
    • Petitions
  • Cases
    • Religious Freedom
    • Marriage and Family
    • Human Sexuality
    • Rights of the Unborn
  • Updates
  • Legal Help
Menu
  • About
  • Institute
    • Blog
    • Background Briefings
    • Issue Resources
    • Historical Documents
    • Petitions
  • Cases
    • Religious Freedom
    • Marriage and Family
    • Human Sexuality
    • Rights of the Unborn
  • Updates
  • Legal Help
Search
Donate
Donate
Menu
  • About
  • Institute
    • Blog
    • Background Briefings
    • Issue Resources
    • Historical Documents
    • Petitions
  • Cases
    • Religious Freedom
    • Marriage and Family
    • Human Sexuality
    • Rights of the Unborn
  • Updates
  • Legal Help

Godfrey v. Spano

Marriage and Family

About this Case

In this case—actually, two consolidated cases—taxpayers in New York challenged a local executive order and a state policy that recognized out-of-state same-sex marriages.  At this time, same-sex marriages were not permitted under New York law.  Although the taxpayer plaintiffs lost in the lower courts they appealed to the Court of Appeals.

Summary of NLF's Brief

We filed a friend-of-the-court making two arguments.  First, and most importantly, we made our famous “salt” argument.  The lower courts had rejected as being circular arguments that New York could limit marriage to one man and one woman because that was the traditional definition.  We noted by way of analogy, that salt was traditionally defined as one molecule of sodium combined with one molecule of chlorine.  Despite this definition being traditional, one simply could not produce salt by combining two molecules of sodium or two molecules of chlorine.  Second, we argued that it was for the legislature and not the courts to define marriage in New York. Sadly, even though the “salt” analogy had been persuasive elsewhere, the Court of Appeals ruled against the taxpayers.

Download Brief

Find a Case​

Search

Browse Cases by Topic

Human Sexuality
Marriage and Family

Rights of the Unborn
Religious Freedom

CONTACT US

757.463.6133
email@nationallegalfoundation.org

Post Office Box 64427
Virginia Beach, VA 23467-4427

Facebook Twitter Rss Envelope

Subscribe to email updates

Scroll to Top